October 30, 2020

1700 words 8 mins read

More Subsidies Alone Wont Fix What Ails US Broadband

More Subsidies Alone Wont Fix What Ails US Broadband

For decades, U.S. taxpayers have thrown countless subsidies, tax breaks, and other perks at entrenched broadband monopolies, hoping that this time we’d finally put that pesky “digital divide” to bed. And while there certainly are countless communities that have been helped by taxpayer-funded projects, there are just as many examples where this money was effectively wasted by unaccountable telecom

monopolies, which often receive millions to billions in handouts in exchange for fiber networks that are routinely only half-deployed.

The reason for our failure should be fairly obvious by now. More often than not, telecom giants face little real scrutiny for their subsidy spending decisions by federal or state lawmakers, most of which are in these monopolies' back pockets. The end result: state and federal lawmakers and regulators that tend to downplay the scope of U.S. telecom market failure, refuse to hold telecom monopolies accountable, and refuse to acknowledge that boring, ordinary corruption is truly why, decades in, American broadband is some of the slowest, patchiest, and most expensive in the world.

Under the Trump administration, this corruption problem was personified to almost comedic effect, with federal regulators literally often indistinguishable from telecom lobbyists. While it shouldn’t be hard for a Biden administration to outperform the mindless Comcast, ATT and Verizon ass kissing that was Trumpism, whether the administration will have the courage to stand up to U.S. telecom monopolies remains to be seen. What is clear is that the incoming administration will be making throwing more subsides at the industry one of its highest priorities:

“Their first major opportunity could come as part of a new coronavirus stimulus package, a top priority for Biden as he prepares to enter the White House in January. The president-elect previously endorsed a House-passed relief bill that includes $4 billion in emergency funds to help low-income Americans stay online in a pandemic that has left tens of millions out of work and strapped for cash. Biden also reaffirmed his commitment to universal broadband on Tuesday as part of a broader preview of his economic-recovery agenda.”

To be clear, including some broadband help that actually reaches end users would be a good thing. And subsidies by and of themselves aren’t necessarily bad. But while the original CARES Act may have been well-intentioned, it included some unrealistic timelines that forced many areas to either rush to spend taxpayer money in haphazard ways, or return it to the government. A follow up proposal that brings some relief to Americans and smaller broadband providers would be welcome. COVID-19 has, after all, brought the issue of broadband into stark relief to those (for whatever reason) who hadn’t yet realized that the technology is essential, and our efforts so far have been decidedly half-assed:

“Students can’t go to school without it. Patients can’t engage in telehealth without it. Governments can’t reach all their citizens with the services people expect unless there is access to it,” said Brad Smith, the president of Microsoft, in an interview. “If there is a silver lining in 2020, it is that all of this has become clear to people. The problem was here before; it just wasn’t as understood as it is now.”

Again though, more subsidies doesn’t do a whole lot if you’re not effectively tracking where broadband is or isn’t available, or where subsidies are spent. We’ve noted more times than we can count that the FCC’s broadband maps are (often by industry lobbying design), effectively useless for actually measuring U.S. broadband; more subsidies can’t fix a problem if you don’t know what the problem is.

More subsidies don’t really address the fact that more than half of Congress is literally a rubber stamp to every fleeting whim of ATT, Comcast, Verizon, Charter, and T-Mobile. Nor can it fix the fact that in many states, corruption is so rampant that telecom giants literally and routinely write anti-competitive telecom law, or state ordinances that hamstring communities' right to make local telecom infrastructure decisions for itself.

More subsidies can’t fix the Trump FCC’s net neutrality repeal, which effectively neutered the agency, making it harder than ever for it to hold incumbent telecom monopolies accountable for much of anything. In fact, if Congress rushes to confirm Nathan Simington, then blocks the appointment of a Democratic Commissioner, the FCC could remain gridlocked at 2-2, and effectively impotent for at least two years. More subsidies can’t fix that.

More subsidies don’t address the fact we routinely, repeatedly, rubber stamp competition and job killing megamergers that all but ensure Americans continue to pay some of the highest-prices in the world, something that was already a problem before a massive economic and public health crisis. More subsides don’t fix our broken antitrust enforcement mechanism that whistles while looking the other direction as merger after merger is gleefully approved, and the resulting domination crushes innovative smaller companies.

Telecom giants have a complete and total stranglehold over telecom policy making on the state and federal level. Yet year after year, we refuse to address or tackle this corruption, let monopolies dictate the lion’s share of U.S. telecom policy, and then stand around with an idiotic look on our faces wondering why the U.S. remains a broadband backwater after throwing so much damn money at the problem.

Author: Karl Bode

Date: 2020-11-30

URL: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20201124/11015345765/more-subsidies-alone-wont-fix-what-ails-us-broadband.shtml


Internal Documents Show The FBI Is Only Interested In Punishing Anti-Trump Speech By Its Employees (2020-11-05) It doesnt pay to anger the man in charge Trumps DOJ is more vindictive than most it appears Documents obtained via a FOIA request by Lawfare shows the FBI is more motivated to hunt down internal critics of this administration than any other it has served previously Two agents involved in the investigation of Hillary Clintons email server have already been served up for punishment by this administr..
Comcast Expands Its Bullshit Usage Caps…In The Middle Of A Pandemic (2020-11-24) Contrary to what some try to claim broadband usage caps have always been bullshit They serve absolutely no technical function do not help manage congestion and exist exclusively to nickel-and-dime captive customers in monopolized US markets Worse they can be used by incumbent ISPs anticompetitively to hamstring competitors in the streaming video and other markets Comcast for years has been slowly ..
Trump’s DOJ Still Pretending Everything Has An ‘Interstate’ Nexus To Throw Federal Charges At Protester (2020-11-04) The Trump Administrations desire to turn protests against police brutality into an antifa conspiracy have failed But not for a lack of trying Federal officers have been sent to major cities still experiencing unrest but arrest data and DOJ press releases show theres very little evidence that coordinated groups of anarchists are behind the violence and property destruction witnessed around the nati..
Content Moderation Case Study: Using Fact Checkers To Create A Misogynist Meme (2019) (2020-11-11) Summary: Many social media sites include fact checkers in order to either block or at least highlight information that is determined to be false or misleading However in some ways that alone can create a content moderation challenge Alan Kyle a privacy and policy analyst noticed this in late 2019 when he came across a meme picture on Instagram from a meme account called memealpyro showing what app..
White House Still Pushing To Slip Section 230 Repeal Into ‘Must Pass’ Military Spending Bill (2020-12-01) This was rumored a week and a half ago and at the time I stated that there was no way in hell it was happening and that it was all just performative nonsense but yesterday Axios reported that the White House is still pushing Congress to insert a total repeal of Section 230 into the must pass National Defense Authorization Act NDAA At the time the story was that Trump would make a trade: he wouldnt..
Microsoft: Bethesda Games Will Be ‘First, Best’ On Xbox, PC (2020-11-20) Several weeks back we discussed how Microsoft and its newly acquired property Bethesda Softworks were making seemingly conflicting statements on what the purchase of the studio meant for beloved franchises like Fallout and Elder Scrolls among others Concerns popped up immediately after the acquisition with people wondering whether the next Fallout game would be siloed to the Xbox and/or PC as oppo..
Daily Deal: The Complete Microsoft Azure Course Bundle (2020-11-10) The Complete Microsoft Azure Course Bundle has 15+ hours of video content and 6 eBooks on Azure Cloud solutions integration and networks Youll learn how to monitor and troubleshoot Azure network resources manage virtual machines with PowerShell use computer vision to detect objects and text in images and much more Its on sale for $30 Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackCo.. Daily Deal: The Complete Microsoft Azure Course Bundle
Content Moderation Case Study: Facebook Attracts International Attention When It Removes A Historic Vietnam War Photo Posted By The Editor-in-Chief Of Norway’s Biggest Newspaper (2016) (2020-11-20) Summary: Tom Egeland a Norwegian author of a number of best-selling fiction books posted a well-known photo known as The Terror of War to Facebook The historic photograph taken by Vietnamese-American photographer Nick Ut depicts a naked Vietnamese girl running from a napalm attack during the Vietnam War Uts iconic photo brought the horrors of the war in Vietnam to viewers around the world But it w..
Content Moderation Case Study: Moderating An Anonymous Social Network (2015) (2020-11-04) Summary: Between around 2013 and 2015 there was a sudden popularity of so-called anonymous social networks A few had existed before but suddenly the market was full of them: Whisper Secret and Yik Yak received the most attention All of them argued that by allowing people to post content anonymously they were helping people allowing them to express their true thoughts rather than repress them Whisp..
New Orleans PD Finally Admits It Uses Facial Recognition Tech After Denying It For Years (2020-11-30) Another large American law enforcement organization has belatedly admitted it uses facial recognition tech after spending years denying it Last month it was the Los Angeles Police Department which had denied using the tech all the way up until 2019 But records obtained by the Los Angeles Times showed the department had used it 30000 times over the past decade When confronted the LAPDs assistant ch..