July 31, 2020

1361 words 7 mins read

There Is No Race To 5G And The US Wouldnt Be Winning Even If There Was

There Is No Race To 5G And The US Wouldnt Be Winning Even If There Was

Data continues to indicate that despite ridiculous oodles of hype, U.S. 5G networks aren’t much to write home about. According to a recent study by OpenSignal, the U.S. ranked dead last in terms of 5G speeds in a 14-country comparison, largely due to our failure to make mid-band spectrum available for public use. Other reports have repeatedly shown that many initial 5G networks are actually slower

than existing 4G networks. Not a great look given the months of DC rhetoric about how the U.S. is in an urgent “race to 5G.” In reality, it’s less of a race and more of a drunken stumble.

While carriers (usually falsely) advertise massive 5G coverage and reality bending improvements at the hands of 5G, consumers' first impression continues to be of the underwhelming variety:

“Millions of people are experiencing 5G for the first time this month. And I imagine they’re asking: Is that all there is? 5G hit a new level of success in the US in October with the launch of the first 5G iPhones and Verizon’s “nationwide” 5G. But the vast majority of Americans are currently getting a 4G-like, slow 5G experience that doesn’t reflect the lofty promises we’ve been hearing for the past few years.”

With smartphone innovation and sales plateauing, wireless carriers and handset vendors alike have been eager to portray 5G as less of a modest evolution and more of a revolution. Claims of 5G all but curing cancer have been common, as have claims that the technology will quickly usher forth the smart cars and smarter cities of tomorrow. 5G hype has also been used to spur network hardware sales, and has also proven useful to goose national security worries by folks eager to heighten tensions with China and boost subsidization of entrenched telecom giants.

But again, if it’s a race, the U.S. sure as hell isn’t winning it:

And this is just overall speed we’re talking about. News outlets, network data nerds, and lawmakers alike routinely fail to discuss price. U.S. consumers already pay some of the highest prices in the developed world for mobile data, a trend that shows no sign of slowing down with 5G. Especially given our recent decisions to all but lobotomize FCC regulators, eliminate net neutrality (which helped control efforts to further nickel and dime U.S. users), and our utter obsession with rubber stamping competition-killing sector consolidation. The race to lower prices (the top request in most consumer surveys) is utterly nonexistent.

There really is no race to 5G. It’s a giant pile of lobbyist nonsense. Users in China aren’t impacted by whether users in Australia or the UK have access to marginally faster networks. And our broadband coverage maps here in the States are so terrible (often by design), the idea that the U.S. could even accurately measure who’s “winning” the deployment race is laughable in and of itself.

5G absolutely will ultimately deliver better speeds, lower latency, and more reliable networks over the next five years. But again, it’s more of a slow, steady evolution than some type of magical, game-changing revolution. But modest evolution doesn’t sell smartphones and network hardware, so here we are.

Author: Karl Bode

Date: 2020-11-10

URL: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20201109/06533445674/there-is-no-race-to-5g-us-wouldnt-be-winning-even-if-there-was.shtml


Poland’s Bid To Get Upload Filters Taken Out Of The EU Copyright Directive Suddenly Looks Much More Hopeful (2020-11-20) As readers of Techdirt will remember one of the biggest defeats for users of the Internet – and for online freedom of expression – was the passage of the EU Copyright Directive last year The law was passed using a fundamentally dishonest argument that it did not require upload filters because they werent explicitly mentioned in the text As a result supporters of the legislation claimed platforms..
DNC Sues Georgia Governor Over His Bullshit Claims Democrats Hacked The State’s Voter Registration System (2020-11-16) The never-ending amount of election related litigation keeps on coming The Trump campaign is still heavily invested in lawsuits – a practice it started before the election and it hasnt scaled back now that its boy has been handed an L Georgia remains a hotly contested state thanks in part to pressure applied by the outbound President and his many minions It will recount all five million votes whi..
What The Election Means For Tech (2020-11-03) If Trump Wins For Republicans bashing Big Tech has become as central to the Culture War as bashing the Big Three Networks once was Demanding neutrality from social media companies has become what net neutrality has been for Democrats: the issue that sucks up all the oxygen in the room except far more politically useful ISPs arent in the content moderation business but social media would be unusabl.. What The Election Means For Tech
Lawsuit Says NYPD Is Still Engaging In Unconstitutional Stops Of New York Residents (2020-11-04) A federal judge shut down the NYPDs stop and frisk program back in 2013 finding the suspicionless stops mainly of minorities were unconstitutional Then-mayor Mike Bloomberg defended the program – often frothily – by claiming it was essential to maintaining order Without stop and frisk the streets would be awash in deadly criminals and their deadly weapons An actual look at the data showed someth..
ICE Briefly Becomes A Stranded Minor: Loses Its Twitter Account For Being Too Young (2020-11-13) Yesterday afternoon the Twitter account of the USs Immigrations and Customs Enforcement ICE briefly disappeared from the internet Was it anti-conservative bias? Nope Was it ICE doing more stupid shit in locking up children and separating them from their parents? Nope Was it ICEs willingness to seize domain names with no evidence claiming counterfeit? Nope It was that ICE had changed the birthday o..
Cities Say ISPs Are Being Cagey About Low-Income Broadband Availability During Covid (2020-11-17) Back in March the Trump FCC put on a big show about a new Keep America Connected Pledge to help broadband users during COVID In it the FCC proudly proclaimed that it had gotten hundreds of ISPs to suspend usage caps and late fees and agree to not disconnect users who couldnt pay for essential broadband service during a pandemic The problem: the 60 day pledge was entirely voluntary temporary and be..
With Simington Vote, The GOP And Big Telecom Maneuver To Cripple The Biden FCC (2020-12-03) Weve noted at length how the GOP is rushing this week to appoint Trump ally Nathan Simington to the FCC Simington youll recall wrote Trumps ridiculous executive order targeting Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act the essential law that protects freedom of expression and innovation on the internet The bumbling attack is necessary youre told to fix the social media censorship of Conservati.. With Simington Vote, The GOP And Big Telecom Maneuver To Cripple The Biden FCC
Government Argues In Court That It Can Kill US Citizens At Will With Zero Judicial Oversight (2020-11-20) The federal government is back in court arguing for its unilateral right to kill US citizens Two journalists who had appeared to have been mistakenly targeted by drone strikes sued the government in 2017 seeking an injunction forbidding their own government from extrajudicially killing them The journalists Ahmad Zaidan and Bilal Kareem both experienced near misses by drone strikes The suspicion th..
White House Offers To Allow Renaming Confederate Bases… In Exchange For Getting Rid Of Section 230 (2020-11-20) Lets state upfront that there is no way in hell this is happening and its all just performative nonsense No one is actually going to do this However the NY Times is reporting that White House chief of staff Mark Meadows has floated the idea of compromise to get the annual NDAA passed after President Trump has whined about it requiring the renaming of military bases named after Confederacy leaders ..
Daily Deal: Black Friday Roundup (2020-11-27) Its Black Friday and weve got some great deals for you! Use the following codes for additional savings throughout the store: BFSAVE20 to save 20% on physical goods sitewide BFSAVE40 to save 40% off apps and software and BFSAVE70 to save 70% off of online courses Check out our highlighted deals below Learn Spanish French Italian German and many more languages with Babbel the popular language-learni..