Is 5G a Race We Want to Win?
There is an interesting article recently published in the English version of a South Korean newspaper, the ChosunILBO, that talks about 5G in China. According to the article, the Chinese 5G rollout is an expensive bust.
There are a number of interesting facts disclosed about the Chinese 5G rollout. First, it’s clear that the rollout is using millimeter wave spectrum. The article says that the 5G
towers in the Chinese networks are being installed about 200 meters apart (600 feet) since the signal from each transmitter travels between 100 and 300 meters. That’s consistent with millimeter-wave hot spots being deployed in downtown cities by Verizon.
It takes a huge number of millimeter-wave cell sites to cover a city, and the article says that by the end of June 2020, the Chinese had installed 410,000 cell sites. The article estimates that to get the same coverage as today’s 4G, the network would eventually need over 10 million cell sites. The article quotes Xiang Ligang, the director-general of the Information Consumption Alliance, a Chinese telecom industry association, who said the plans are to build one million new cell sites in each of the next three years.
The 5G coverage isn’t seeing wide acceptance. The article cites a recent Chinese survey where over 73% of the public says there is no need to buy 5G phones. This matched the findings from another survey that also said the public saw no need for 5G.
One of the more interesting things cited in the article is that the 5G cell sites use a lot of energy and that starting in August, China Unicom has taken to shutting the cell sites down from 9 PM until 9 AM daily to save on electricity costs. They say each cell site is using triple the power of a 4G cell site, and there are a lot of sites to power. The new 5G specifications include a provision to significantly reduce power consumption for 5G cell sites, but in the early days of deployment, it looks like this has gone in the wrong direction.
The article concludes that the Chinese 5G experiment might end up as an economic bust. What’s interesting about this article is that a lot of the same things can be said about 5G in South Korea. It’s been reported that South Korea has the most significant percentage penetration of 5G handsets, but that the public has mostly been panning the service.
None of this is surprising. The 5G deployment using millimeter wave spectrum is an outdoor technology and can only be brought indoors by installing numerous 5G transmitters inside a building since the spectrum won’t pass through walls. There is no doubt that the millimeter-wave signals are fast, but as has been demonstrated here, the reception of signal is squirrely. Apparently, bandwidth comes and goes by a simple twist of the hand, and the user’s body can block the millimeter-wave signals. Add that to the inability to continue with a connection when walking into a building or around the corner of a building, and the millimeter-wave product doesn’t sound particularly user friendly.
The outdoor product possibly makes sense in places where people stay and work outside, such as public markets. But it’s not an inviting technology for people who are only outside to go between buildings or to commute.
There are no indications that Verizon intends to deploy the product widely in the US, or at least not in the same manner that would cover a city in cell sites every 600 feet.
There has been a huge amount of hype in this country about being in a race with the Chinese over the deployment of 5G. But after seeing articles like this, perhaps our best strategy is to lay back and wait until 5G equipment gets cheaper and until the new 5G cell sites are made energy efficient. For now, it doesn’t sound like a race we want to win. Written by Doug Dawson, President at CCG ConsultingFollow CircleID on TwitterMore under: Broadband, Mobile Internet, Telecom
Author: Doug Dawson
|The Upload Speed Lie (2020-11-04)||In the 2020 Broadband Deployment Report the FCC made the following claim The vast majority of Americans surpassing 85% now have access to fixed terrestrial broadband service at 250/25 Mbps The FCC makes this claim based upon the data provided to it by the countrys ISPs on Form 477 We know the data reported by the ISPs is badly flawed in the over-reporting of download speeds Still weve paid little ..|
|WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center Registers Its 50,000th “Cybersquatting” Case (2020-12-01)||The WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center on Monday announced it had registered its 50000th cybersquatting case The 50000th case just received by WIPO coincides with the organizations 20th anniversary on November 20 2020 WIPO reported that to date it has administered 50000 UDRP-based proceedings covering almost 91000 domain names involving parties from over 180 countries Noteworthy highlights: Inc..|
|SpaceX Starlink Beta, Phase Two (2020-10-29)||The app screenshot for Starlink public beta is made available for iOS and Android devices According to an email Starlink has moved into the second phase of its beta program nicknamed the better than nothing beta which feels a bit like monopoly hubris to me It may be better than nothing but it is not as good as the initial beta which was free Participants will pay $99 per month for the service and ..|
|Starlink Will Be Priced to Be Affordable (2020-11-16)||Spacexs Starlink User Terminal SpaceX Charging more in affluent markets will increase revenue and tend to reduce the digital divide good business and good karma SpaceX is now serving customers aka beta testers in the northern United States They will soon be doing so in Southern Canada and recently announced that Germany where they have applied for permission and have begun construction on two grou..|
|Goodbye Marilyn Cade (2020-11-09)||In memory of Marilyn Cade 1947-2020 Marilyn Cade was an exceptionally hardworking always gracious leader in ICANN and IGF She was a strong supporter of US interests at ITU and a member of the US delegation at the WCIT Dozens have spoken of her at a memorial site including Vint Cerf: Marilyn was an elemental force in the ICANN IGF and policy worlds She was an advocate who could be counted upon to s..|
|US Election-Related Web Properties Prone to Fraud and Misinformation Due to Lack of Domain Security (2020-10-15)||Co-authored by CSCs Sue Watts and Quinn Taggart The risks of fraud and disinformation in the US election process have been hiding in plain sight CSCs new research finds that a large majority of web domains closely linked to the campaign websites for Joe Biden and Donald Trump lack basic domain security protocols and are prone to domain spoofing tactics This makes them a potential target for hacker..|
|Donuts Acquires Afilias (2020-11-19)||Donuts and Afilias announced today that Donuts is acquiring Afilias in a deal that is expected to close in December 2020 for an undisclosed amount The combined entities will support over 25 million domain names spanning well over 400 TLDs The deal will not include certain Afilias businesses such as the mobile software and registrar businesses which will remain with Afilias original group of invest..|
|The Magnitude of the Urban Digital Divide (2020-10-19)||The web is full of stories of rural areas with no broadband options and Ive spent a lot of time in the last few decades helping rural areas get better broadband There has not been nearly as much coverage of the huge broadband gap in urban areas There are a lot of urban homes that cant afford broadband and in many cases got bypassed when the telcos and/or cable companies built their networks I just.. The Magnitude of the Urban Digital Divide|
|Internet Society Seeks Nominations for 2021 Board of Trustees (2020-11-10)||Are you passionate about preserving the global open Internet? Do you have experience in Internet standards development or public policy? If so please consider applying for a seat on the Internet Society Board of Trustees The Internet Society supports and promotes the development of the Internet as a global technical infrastructure a resource to enrich peoples lives and a force for good in society ..|
|Cybersecurity Considerations in the Work-From-Home Era (2020-12-03)||Verisign is deeply committed to protecting our critical internet infrastructure from potential cybersecurity threats and to keeping up to date on the changing cyber landscape Over the years cybercriminals have grown more sophisticated adapting to changing business practices and diversifying their approaches in non-traditional ways We have seen security threats continue to evolve in 2020 as many bu..|