June 20, 2020

1463 words 7 mins read

The Magnitude of the Urban Digital Divide

The Magnitude of the Urban Digital Divide

The web is full of stories of rural areas with no broadband options, and I’ve spent a lot of time in the last few decades helping rural areas get better broadband. There has not been nearly as much coverage of the huge broadband gap in urban areas. There are a lot of urban homes that can’t afford broadband and, in many cases, got bypassed when the telcos and/or cable companies built their networks


I just saw a statistic that made me realize the magnitude of the urban broadband divide. There have always been many urban homes that don’t have broadband, but the issue took on new importance when schools were forced to send students home to work. I read an article in the Democrat and Chronicle, from Rochester, New York that says that 20% of residences in New York City don’t have access to home broadband. That’s a pretty typical percentage in looking at cities across the country. The statistic that astounded me was that this translates into 750,000 students who don’t have a way to tackle schoolwork from home.

That number is mind-boggling. There are more students in NYC without home broadband than the total number of Alaska, Vermont, Wyoming, or Washington DC residents. The article says that the percentage of homes without broadband is in the same 20% range in Rochester and Buffalo. In Syracuse, the percentage of homes without broadband is much higher, at 32%. Nationwide, my firm has studied urban markets where the percentage of homes without broadband ranges from under 10% to as high as 35%.

We know the primary reasons that homes don’t have broadband. Surveys and studies over the years in different markets have uncovered the same list of primary reasons homes don’t have broadband. Some homes simply aren’t interested in broadband and wouldn’t use it if it was free. Some homes have low broadband needs and are happy with what they can get from a cellular plan. The biggest single barrier is the price broadband has grown to be more expensive over time, and many homes have a hard time justifying paying for broadband when they are struggling to pay for food or rent. Some homes can afford broadband but can’t also afford to keep a working computer in the home. Some people don’t know how to use a computer and need training in basic computer skills. The last reason we see given for not having broadband is a dislike for the way that ISPs and social media misuse personal data.

Around the country, some communities have found solutions to some of these problems. The gigantic challenge is how to apply solutions at the scale of a big city. How can a city provide digital literacy training on computer skills to several hundred thousand people? How do you get hundreds of thousands of computers into homes that need them? And the big dollar question is how to subsidize the cost of a monthly broadband connection to half a million homes.

What’s scary is that every other city is similar, with some in even worse shape than New York City. How do you scale up and provide solutions when the universe of people on the wrong side of the digital divide is 10 million to 20 million?

Local communities have tackled some of these issues during the pandemic. I’ve talked to rural counties that are making sure that every student has a computer at home and that every student has enough broadband to connect to school servers usually using cellular hot spots. However, local governments are not going to be able to keep paying the fees for home broadband even in a small community that will add up to a lot of money over time.

We can’t shy away from tackling digital divide issues just because the problem is so large and is found in almost every community. Local solutions can make a real difference, particularly in smaller communities but the magnitude of the digital divide is too immense to easily tackle in larger cities. Written by Doug Dawson, President at CCG ConsultingFollow CircleID on TwitterMore under: Access Providers, Broadband, Policy & Regulation, Telecom

Author: Doug Dawson

Date: 2020-10-19

URL: http://www.circleid.com/posts/20201019-the-magnitude-of-the-urban-digital-divide/


Authenticated Resolution and Adaptive Resolution: Security and Navigational Enhancements to the DNS (2020-11-19) The Domain Name System DNS has become the fundamental building block for navigating from names to resources on the internet DNS has been employed continuously ever since its introduction in 1983 by essentially every internet-connected application and device that wants to interact online Emerging from an era where interconnection rather than information security was the primary motivation DNS has g..
The Good Old Days in the Cryptography Wars (2020-10-24) Colossus the worlds first electronic computer used to help decipher the Lorenz-encrypted Tunny messages between Hitler and his generals during World War II Photo: John Levine The 20th century was the golden age of surveillance High-speed communication went either by telegraph and telephone which needed a license from the government or by radio which anyone can listen to Codes were manual or electr..
Brand Abuse and IP Infringements – Part 2: Enforcement and Return on Investment (2020-11-12) In the first article in this two-part series we looked at the impact of brand abuse and infringements against intellectual property IP on an organizations brand value In this second article we delve into how action against enforceable infringements can deliver tangible return on investment ROI for a brand and demonstrate the importance of a robust brand protection program Enforceable infringements..
OneWeb Is Out of Bankruptcy, but Not Out of the Woods (2020-11-25) OneWeb which declared bankruptcy in May has reorganized and emerged from bankruptcy Bharti Global an Indian telecommunication conglomerate and the British government each own 422% of the new company and most of the rest is owned by previous investors SoftBank and Hughes Network Systems Hughes will continue work on ground infrastructure and marketing and the original joint venture with Airbus which.. OneWeb Is Out of Bankruptcy, but Not Out of the Woods
ICANN Should Keep Content Regulation and Other Arbitrary Rules Out of Registry Contracts (2020-11-23) The domain name system is not the place to police speech ICANN is legally bound not to act as the Internets speech police but its legal commitments are riddled with exceptions and aspiring censors have already used those exceptions in harmful ways This was one factor that made the failed takeover of the ORG registry such a dangerous situation But now ICANN has an opportunity to curb this abuse and..
A Look at DNS Trends and What the Future May Hold (2020-10-28) We used to think of computer networks as being constructed using two fundamental common infrastructure components: names and addresses Every connected device had a stable protocol address to allow all other devices to initiate a communication transaction with this device by addressing a data packet to this protocol address And every device was also associated with a name allowing human users and h..
Another ICANN Meeting Concluded With No Action on DNS Abuse or Privacy/Proxy Policy (2020-11-04) Co-authored by Russell Pangborn and Syed Abedi of Seed IP Law Group The ICANN 69 meeting has come to a close with no progress on DNS abuse or implementation of the Privacy/Proxy Services Accreditation policy PPSAI While ICANN is uniquely positioned to do so it refuses to do anything proactive about DNS abuse with its executives overtly attempting to limit its role to data collection Moreover its r..
Starlink Will Be Priced to Be Affordable (2020-11-16) Spacexs Starlink User Terminal SpaceX Charging more in affluent markets will increase revenue and tend to reduce the digital divide good business and good karma SpaceX is now serving customers aka beta testers in the northern United States They will soon be doing so in Southern Canada and recently announced that Germany where they have applied for permission and have begun construction on two grou..
Backlash Over Potential Firing of U.S. Election Cybersecurity’s Top Official (2020-11-17) CISA Director Chris Krebs on the ongoing effort to secure the 2020 election and rumor control The Electronic Frontier Foundation EFF along with over forty other cybersecurity experts and organizations are urging the White House to keep politics out of securing this months election in the US The concern arose following a Reuters report that the top US cybersecurity official Christopher Krebs Homela..
Internet Governance and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Part 6: Articles 18-19 (2020-12-01) Articles 18-19: Freedoms of Thought and Opinion Co-authored by Klaus Stoll and Prof Sam Lanfranco1 Internet Governance like all governance needs guiding principles from which policy making and acceptable behavior are derived Identifying the fundamental principles to guide Internet ecosystem policy making around digital citizenship and around the integrity of digital practices and behavior can and ..