July 12, 2020

1713 words 9 mins read

Cares Act Broadband Funding Came With Unrealistic Deadlines Ruining Good Intentions

Cares Act Broadband Funding Came With Unrealistic Deadlines Ruining Good Intentions

As our current Techdirt Greenhouse panel is exploring, COVID-19 has shone a very bright light on the importance of widely available, affordable broadband. Nearly 42 million Americans lack access to any broadband whatsoever–double FCC estimates. 83 million are stuck under a monopoly. Millions can’t afford service thanks to a lack of competition among very powerful, government pampered telecom mono

polies, despite untold billions in federal and state subsidies for fiber networks that routinely, consistently, wind up only half deployed.

Instead of tackling the corruption that makes state and federal regulatory capture possible, or embracing policies that drive more competition to market (ATT, Verizon and Comcast don’t much like either), the U.S. routinely enjoys just throwing more taxpayer money at the problem in the hopes things somehow, this time, improve. While that’s sometimes certainly a helpful path, more often than not the money doled out to industry giants gets misdirected and wasted, in large part because (and pardon me for being redundant), nobody bothers to genuinely hold U.S. telecom incumbents accountable for much of anything, ever.

The latest case in point: last March Congress passed the CARES Act, our last (and only) major relief package for those struggling under COVID-19. Included in the bill was $375 million in new funding for various telecommunications related government projects. A chunk of that money ($100 million) was earmarked for additional broadband deployment grants under the RUS’s broadband deployment pilot program, which was originally created in 2018 with $600 million in funding.

The problem: restrictions mean that many locations were forced to rush and spend that money before the end of the year, or it gets returned to the federal government. Given the time-intense complexity of getting broadband deployed to rural areas, the obvious reality that COVID isn’t going away, and a broken Congress' inability to pass any more public or infrastructure aid during a historic health crisis, that’s obviously pissing some people off:

An extremely dumb thing that Congress did was require that CARES Act funding earmarked for broadband be spent—and the work completed—by December 31. Ninety days days is not even vaguely enough time for that work to be done, so a bunch of the money will go for shoddy work.

Waldo Jaquith (@waldojaquith) October 29, 2020

To be clear, the money is going toward some genuinely good projects in many areas. But the restrictions will force behavior that’s not well-aligned with doing things correctly or ensuring that the money is spent as intended (just ask Mississippi, which is currently embroiled in a fight with ATT after the state said the giant took $283 Million for broadband networks never deployed). Forcing municipalities to rush projects in order to spend the money, lest they lose it, is now pissing off folks from New York to Alabama:

“Congress put tight restrictions on how the funds could be used, including not allowing any expenses other than those directly related to the outbreak and not allowing any spending past Dec. 30. The expenses also have to have originated after March 27, not prior to the virus.

That deadline was set in the CARES Act when many believed the virus would be gone by the end of 2020.

“Right now, I think the time deadline is the biggest challenge (to spending the money)” Butler said.

“Since May, there have been many things that have come across our desk that really look like great things and we would have liked to have done that just don’t get past the allowable use test,” Butler said.

U.S. broadband dysfunction is a problem a generation in the making. We’re not going to fix it in a mad dash by throwing taxpayer money at it, then rushing those in charge of building complicated, regional solutions. We’re a country that simply refuses to come to terms with the fact that ATT and Comcast literally write state and federal telecom law always with an eye on hamstringing potential competition and protecting dominance. Fixing the problem requires recognizing the private market alone can’t and won’t fix it, shaking off lobbying influence, and developing smart, creative strategies that drive additional competition to market.

Instead, the Trump administration gutted the FCC and consumer protections at lobbyist behest, doled out tens of billions in utterly pointless tax cuts to giants like ATT, and mindlessly rubber stamped job and competition eroding megamergers. The result: more layoffs, less competition, higher prices, and less accountability for some of the least liked monopolies in American industry. Brilliant. Even when America has tried to craft a “national broadband plan” (as we did in 2010 under Obama’s first FCC boss, Julius Genachowski), it has comically refused to seriously acknowledge the lack of competition among powerful monopolies as the root cause of the U.S. broadband industry’s dysfunction. Largely because timid U.S. leaders don’t like making NSA allies ATT and Verizon mad.

Through the fall, winter, and Spring as COVID-19 surges, pressure will be greater than ever on lawmakers to do more to fix U.S. broadband, and do it right now. It might be nice if, for once, we recognize than mindlessly scattering subsidies around has never truly worked if you’re not willing to tackle (or for many “experts,” even acknowledge) regulatory capture and monopoly domination in the first place. U.S. broadband policy consistently operates in a state of delusion and denial, and the end result couldn’t be more obvious.

Author: Karl Bode

Date: 2020-11-05

URL: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20201103/07292645636/cares-act-broadband-funding-came-with-unrealistic-deadlines-ruining-good-intentions.shtml


‘Activist’ Investor Elliott Management Sells Stake In AT&T After Encouraging Mass Firings (2020-11-19) In ATT executives heads the 2015 $67 billion acquisition of DirecTV and the 2018 $86 billion acquisition of Time Warner were supposed to be the cornerstones of the companys efforts to dominate video and online video advertising Instead the megadeals made ATT possibly one of the most heavily indebted companies in the world To recoup that debt ATT quickly ramped up its efforts to nickel-and-dime use.. ‘Activist’ Investor Elliott Management Sells Stake In AT&T After Encouraging Mass Firings
Daily Deal: The Electrical And Circuits Engineering Bundle (2020-11-19) The Electrical And Circuits Engineering Bundle has 13 courses designed to help you better understand electrical circuits machines power generation and electronics Youll start by learning basic concepts such as current voltage power and energy regarding the electric circuits as well as the basic laws of electric circuits as resistance conductance the combination of resistance and conductance KVL KC..
Happy 20th Birthday To ‘No One Lives Forever’, The Classic PC Game That Can’t Be Sold Today Thanks To IP (2020-11-11) There are a great many interesting arguments we tend to have over both the purpose of copyright law and how effectively its current application aligns with that purpose Still we are on fairly solid legal footing when we state that the main thrust of copyright was supposed to be to drive more and better content to the public Much of the disagreement we tend to have with naysayers revolves around wh..
Verizon, NYC Settle Lawsuit Over Verizon’s Empty Fiber Promises (2020-12-01) Like ATT Frontier and other US telcos Verizon has a long rich history of taking tax breaks regulatory favors and taxpayer subsidies in exchange for networks it only half deploys That was the case in the 90s when Verizon took a several billion tax breaks from the state of Pennsylvania in exchange for networks it never deployed It was also the case in New York City where Verizon was sued by the city.. Verizon, NYC Settle Lawsuit Over Verizon’s Empty Fiber Promises
The Trump FCC Has Failed To Protect Low-Income Americans During A Health Crisis (2020-12-04) As America struggles with a deadly and historic health crisis millions of Americans risk getting kicked offline due to economic hardship At a time when stable access to power broadband and water are essential for survival government agencies tasked with representing and defending the public welfare have been asleep at the wheel Millions of Americans risk losing access to essential utilities as ove..
This Week In Techdirt History: November 8th - 14th (2020-11-14) Five Years Ago This week in 2015 we looked at early warnings of the EUs all-out attack on hyperlinks while the silly Monkey Selfie lawsuit was winding forward and a new surprise player entered the copyright fight over Happy Birthday The MPAAs attempt to sneak SOPA in the back door was rejected but the agency was getting cozy with the House Judiciary Committee And we looked at the unsurprising trio..
Mine, Mine, Mine! Nintendo Neuters The Cool Ways People, Groups Are Using ‘Animal Crossing’ (2020-11-24) To be honest Animal Crossing was always going to be a hit Its just the perfect distillation of the Nintendo experience: a cutesy social experience couched in harmless video game fun Still one unanticipated side effect of the global COVID-19 pandemic was how plenty of people and groups turned to the game for new and innovative ways of connecting with others Examples abound including players buildin..
New York Schools Putting Students In The Crosshairs Of Tech That Targets Minorities, Thinks Broom Handles Are Guns (2020-12-03) Were turning over discipline of school kids to cops and their tech and its just making existing problems even worse Weve seen the problems inherent in facial recognition tech And its not just us – this so-called leftist rag according to our anonymous critics Its also the National Institute of Standards and Technology NIST Its study of 189 facial recognition algorithms uncovered why most legislato..
This Week In Techdirt History: November 22nd - 28th (2020-11-28) Five Years Ago This week in 2015 the attacks on encryption continued with David Camerons former speechwriter publishing an incredibly dumb article in the Telegraph and Dianne Feinstein contradicting her month-old fearmongering about cybersecurity with demands for encryption backdoors while a supposed ISIS encryption manual that people had been freaking out about turned out to be a guide for journa..
Zoom Gets An FTC Wrist Slap For Misleading Users On Security, Encryption (2020-11-12) In many ways Zoom is an incredible success story A relative unknown before the pandemic the companys userbase exploded from 10 million pre-pandemic to 300 million users worldwide as of last April One problem: like so many modern tech companies its security and privacy practices werent up to snuff Researchers found that the companys end-to-end encryption didnt actually exist The company also came u..