June 29, 2020

1547 words 8 mins read

Space X Tempers Expectations As Starlink Better Than Nothing Broadband Beta Starts

Space X Tempers Expectations As Starlink Better Than Nothing Broadband Beta Starts

Space X has begun sending invites out to folks interested in participating in the company’s Starlink low-orbit satellite broadband service. Users took to Reddit to note that Starlink is promising users speeds of 50-100 Mbps downstream for about $100 per month, plus $500 down for a connection terminal and antenna. The company is also promising significantly lower latency (20 to 40ms) than what you'

ll typically see with satellite broadband (often 200ms or higher). The best part, no monthly usage caps and overage fees (so far):

“Expect to see data speeds vary from 50Mbps to 150Mbps and latency from 20ms to 40ms over the next several months as we enhance the Starlink system. There will also be brief periods of no connectivity at all.

As we launch more satellites, install more ground stations, and improve our networking software, data speed, latency, and uptime will improve dramatically. For latency, we expect to achieve 16ms to 19ms by summer 2021.

The Starlink phased-array user terminal, which is more advanced than what’s in fighter jets, plus mounting tripod and Wi-Fi router, costs $499 and the monthly subscription costs $99.

Space X is clearly attempting to get ahead of expectations that the offering poses a serious challenge to entrenched U.S. broadband monopolies. So much so that the company is calling this the “Better Than Nothing” beta. And for good reason. As we’ve noted previously, Musk himself has repeatedly acknowledged the system will lack the capacity to provide service to anything outside of rural markets. From a conference earlier this year:

“The challenge for anything that is space-based is that the size of the cell is gigantic… it’s not good for high-density situations,” Musk said. “We’ll have some small number of customers in LA. But we can’t do a lot of customers in LA because the bandwidth per cell is simply not high enough.”

How Space X decides to manage capacity constraints should prove interesting. With the FCC and net neutrality rules effectively lobotomized, it wouldn’t be particularly surprising to see throttling implemented to help manage the load, a reminder that it’s hard to beat traditional fiber. Still, Starlink could do some good things in a country where 42 million Americans are currently unable to access any broadband whatsoever. Even though for many Americans cost is the biggest obstacle, and it’s not particularly clear a $600 first month bill is something a lot of these struggling users can actually afford.

In other words, Starlink will be great if your only option is currently traditional satellite broadband, a technology long despised for being slow, expensive, capped, and having high latency. It’s also probably great for users who’ve been forced to rely exclusively on a capped and throttled wireless connection. And it’s particularly great for folks who’ve been just out of reach of any broadband entirely. But how well Starlink differentiates itself will probably come down to how annoying its network management practices wind up being on a crowded, fully loaded network.

For most everybody else it will be a non starter. And you can probably expect a disconnect between Starlink’s attempt to set realistic expectations (which should be applauded for a company not unfamiliar with hype), and regulators eager to portray Starlink as something more than the sum of its parts.

Captured regulators from both parties historically enjoy portraying emerging broadband technologies as near-miraculous examples of why regulatory oversight isn’t needed. As in, “we don’t need competitive policies because amazing competition is already happening.” Or, as Michael Powell did with doomed powerline broadband technology in the early aughts, trying to claim that pandering mindlessly to ATT, Verizon, and Comcast is a good idea because the free market and innovation will swoop in and save the public from monopolistic harms.

That may be true in more functional, healthier markets, but it’s simply not true in the monopoly-dominated U.S. telecom sector. As such, the several million users Starlink is expected to help is a drop in the bucket in a country where 42 million Americans lack access to any broadband, 83 million more are trapped under a broadband monopoly, and tens of millions more are stuck with an apathetic duopoly. Starlink will be more akin to a band aid than a cure. Raise a skeptical, arched eyebrow at anybody claiming otherwise in the months to come.

Author: Karl Bode

Date: 2020-11-03

URL: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20201102/09020745630/space-x-tempers-expectations-as-starlink-better-than-nothing-broadband-beta-starts.shtml


Facial Recognition Company’s Employees Abused Tech To Sexually Harass Coworkers (2020-11-09) Someone wants to out-evil Clearview Now there are a lot of questionable facial recognition tech vendors but most have decided to cede most hated to Clearview But another startup thinks it should generate as much ill will as possible before securing prominent marketplace status The unanswered question I guess is whether to direct your AI-enabled sociopathy at random individuals or your own coworker..
Bullshit Broadband Usage Caps Are Hugely Profitable During A Pandemic (2020-11-18) Weve noted for years how broadband providers have increasingly imposed arbitrary confusing and punitive usage caps and overage fees to cash in on the lack of competition in US broadband Not only have industry executives admitted these limits arent technically necessary theyve increasingly been abused to hamstring competitors AT&T for example doesnt impose the limits on its broadband customers who .. Bullshit Broadband Usage Caps Are Hugely Profitable During A Pandemic
While Social Media Was Quick To Highlight And Limit The Spread Of False Claims Of Election Victory, Traditional Media Just Let It Flow (2020-11-04) For four years all weve been hearing about is how social media was this terrible source of disinformation that had to be regulated because they were destroying democracy and all that And so what happened last night/early this morning when Donald Trump falsely tried to claim he had won prior to all the votes being counted? Twitter and Facebook both reacted pretty quickly to flag the information and..
About Time: NY Governor Cuomo Signs Anti-SLAPP Law (2020-11-12) Back in July we noted that after years of living with a pathetically weak anti-SLAPP bill the NY legislature had finally approved a more significant anti-SLAPP bill Its incredible that it has taken this long given that much of the media industry is based in New York and for so many years has been open to a barrage of ridiculous SLAPP suits since the old law only covered speech made in the process ..
Daily Deal: The Professional Video And Audio Production Bundle (2020-11-20) The Professional Video and Audio Production Bundle has 6 courses to help you create edit and produce videos and music like a pro Youll learn recording processing mixing live streaming and more Its on sale for $40 and use the code SAVE15NOV to get an additional 15% off on this bundle and other deals throughout the store Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackCommerce A portio..
Reform The DMCA? OK, But Only If It’s Done Really, Really Carefully (2020-12-04) The DMCA is a weird law Its comprised of two almost completely unrelated provisions: Section 512 with its platform safe harbors and Section 1201 which forbids circumventing technological measures Both parts are full of problems but to the extent that the DMCA provides platforms with liability protection via the safe harbors it is also a critically important law We are therefore fans of the DMCA be..
‘Activist’ Investor Elliott Management Sells Stake In AT&T After Encouraging Mass Firings (2020-11-19) In ATT executives heads the 2015 $67 billion acquisition of DirecTV and the 2018 $86 billion acquisition of Time Warner were supposed to be the cornerstones of the companys efforts to dominate video and online video advertising Instead the megadeals made ATT possibly one of the most heavily indebted companies in the world To recoup that debt ATT quickly ramped up its efforts to nickel-and-dime use.. ‘Activist’ Investor Elliott Management Sells Stake In AT&T After Encouraging Mass Firings
Daily Deal: The Complete Microsoft Azure Course Bundle (2020-11-10) The Complete Microsoft Azure Course Bundle has 15+ hours of video content and 6 eBooks on Azure Cloud solutions integration and networks Youll learn how to monitor and troubleshoot Azure network resources manage virtual machines with PowerShell use computer vision to detect objects and text in images and much more Its on sale for $30 Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackCo.. Daily Deal: The Complete Microsoft Azure Course Bundle
Disappointing: Netflix Decides To Settle With Chooseco LLC Over ‘Bandersnatch’ Lawsuit (2020-11-25) Well its been quite a stupid and frustrating run in the trademark lawsuit between Netflix and Chooseco LLC the folks behind Choose Your Own Adventure books from our youth At issue was the Black Mirror production Bandersnatch in which the viewer takes part in an interactive film where they help decide the outcome The main character is creating a book he refers to as a choose your own adventure book..
Daily Deal: Apple MacBook Air (Refurbished) (2020-11-18) This refurbished Apple MacBook Air gives you superb tech features for a more affordable price It has an Intel Core i5 16GHz processor and Intel HD Graphics 6000 video adapter for fast and high PC performance It comes with a 133 widescreen TFT LED-backlit active-matrix glossy display and 1440x900 native resolution giving you photos videos and texts in a clearer and more detailed view With a 54Wh Li..