September 1, 2020

1468 words 7 mins read

What Does an Administration Change Mean for the FCC?

What Does an Administration Change Mean for the FCC?

Just as the last change in administration changed the course of the FCC, so will the swing back to a Democratic administration. If you’ve been reading me for a few years, you know I am a big believer in the regulatory pendulum. Inevitably, when a regulatory agency like the FCC swings too far in any direction, it’s inevitable that it will eventually swing back the other way.

If I had to character

ize the current FCC, the biggest theme of the last four years has been their stances that were exceedingly in favor of the big carriers. In ruling after ruling, they helped fulfill the big telcos and cable companies' wish list with nothing bigger than the nearly complete deregulation of broadband. The term deregulation isn’t even the right word because the current FCC took themselves out of the game as regulators. Chairman Ajit Pai has characterized their treatment of broadband as light-touch regulation, but it went way beyond that, and the FCC eliminated its own ability to regulate broadband.

A new FCC is almost surely going to try to re-regulate broadband, and they are likely to do so by pushing for the introduction of net neutrality. This is not going to be an easy task. Obviously, a new FCC can undo things done by a former FCC, but by completely writing the agency out of the regulatory game, the new FCC will have to start over from scratch. They are going to have to go through the full cycle of steps required to reintroduce any semblance of broadband re-regulation. That means adopting a policy, seeking several rounds of public comments, and then finally voting to reintroduce net neutrality and other broadband regulation. Then will come the inevitable lawsuits that will tack more time onto the process. I’m betting we’re three years into a new FCC before we see broadband regulation back on the books.

As part of the re-regulation process, a new FCC will likely put back the FCC complaint process. Most of America doesn’t realize that the current FCC does nothing with customer complaints about ISPs complaints are simply forwarded to the Federal Trade Commission.

Hopefully, a new FCC will continue with the process of setting aside unused spectrum for rural broadband. This is one of the few areas where the current FCC stood up to big carriers but those carriers weren’t really bothered since they don’t use most licensed spectrum in rural markets.

I’m hoping the new FCC takes a hard look at the disaster of broadband reporting and mapping. The current FCC has delayed implementation of new mapping for several years I’ve always believed that they don’t want to see an honest count of rural homes without broadband because the numbers will be double of what the FCC claims today.

I think a new FCC will update the national definition of broadband. It’s a travesty to continue to define broadband at 25/3 Mbps when eighty percent of America buys broadband from cable or fiber companies. The main outcome of an update of broadband definition will hopefully be an honest count of homes with inferior broadband. An added bonus will be that slow broadband technologies should stop being eligible for federal grant funding. A new definition of broadband needs to recognize the new crisis of slow upload speeds that have made it so miserable for workers and students send home during the pandemic.

I hope the new FCC gets off the 5G bandwagon. The current FCC blindly followed the administration in pushing the story that America is losing the mythical 5G war. Outside of 5G, the current FCC has been in favor of letting the markets solve technology issues. 5G will be whatever it’s going to be, and our national regulators should be not be pushing 5G or hindering it they just need to stay out of the way of market progress. Written by Doug Dawson, President at CCG ConsultingFollow CircleID on TwitterMore under: Access Providers, Broadband, Mobile Internet, Net Neutrality, Policy & Regulation, Telecom

Author: Doug Dawson

Date: 2020-11-17


Reaching Critical Mass for Gigabit Connections (2020-10-27) Overall percentage of subscribers provisioned for gigabit speed increased 133% to nearly 5% in the second quarter of 2020 Source: 2Q20 OpenVault Broadband Insights The statistics concerning the number of gigabit fiber customers in the US is eye-opening OpenVault tracks the percentage of customers provisioned at various broadband speeds At the end of 2019 the company reported that 281% of all house.. Reaching Critical Mass for Gigabit Connections
First RIPE NCC “Seizure of IPv4 Addresses” – Is This the Beginning of IPv4 as Collateral? (2020-11-25) In a publication released on October 2 2020 RIPE NCC reported its first seizure of IPv4 registration rights pursuant to a Dutch court order Pursuant to the order RIPE NCC effectuated a transfer of the IP Addresses from the liquidating debtor to its creditor Although these IP Addresses could not be owned they were apparently not legacy Thus they conferred no property rights the registration rights ..
Brand Abuse and IP Infringements – Part 2: Enforcement and Return on Investment (2020-11-12) In the first article in this two-part series we looked at the impact of brand abuse and infringements against intellectual property IP on an organizations brand value In this second article we delve into how action against enforceable infringements can deliver tangible return on investment ROI for a brand and demonstrate the importance of a robust brand protection program Enforceable infringements..
ICANN Should Keep Content Regulation and Other Arbitrary Rules Out of Registry Contracts (2020-11-23) The domain name system is not the place to police speech ICANN is legally bound not to act as the Internets speech police but its legal commitments are riddled with exceptions and aspiring censors have already used those exceptions in harmful ways This was one factor that made the failed takeover of the ORG registry such a dangerous situation But now ICANN has an opportunity to curb this abuse and..
The Good Old Days in the Cryptography Wars (2020-10-24) Colossus the worlds first electronic computer used to help decipher the Lorenz-encrypted Tunny messages between Hitler and his generals during World War II Photo: John Levine The 20th century was the golden age of surveillance High-speed communication went either by telegraph and telephone which needed a license from the government or by radio which anyone can listen to Codes were manual or electr..
SpaceX Starlink Beta, Phase Two (2020-10-29) The app screenshot for Starlink public beta is made available for iOS and Android devices According to an email Starlink has moved into the second phase of its beta program nicknamed the better than nothing beta which feels a bit like monopoly hubris to me It may be better than nothing but it is not as good as the initial beta which was free Participants will pay $99 per month for the service and ..
US Election-Related Web Properties Prone to Fraud and Misinformation Due to Lack of Domain Security (2020-10-15) Co-authored by CSCs Sue Watts and Quinn Taggart The risks of fraud and disinformation in the US election process have been hiding in plain sight CSCs new research finds that a large majority of web domains closely linked to the campaign websites for Joe Biden and Donald Trump lack basic domain security protocols and are prone to domain spoofing tactics This makes them a potential target for hacker..
Disinformation and Our Technology Industries (2020-11-13) It was interesting to see that albeit belatedly the American media started to stop giving Trump opportunities to spew out his lies across the country and beyond It obviously had now reached a point where the media realized that if they continued to provide Trump with their avenues this would make them accomplices in inciting violence Is this going to be a turning point? Disinformation has become a..
A Brief Look at the Domain Attack Surface of Streaming Media Companies (2020-10-29) The term attack surface is often heard in cybersecurity conversations It refers to the sum of all possible attack vectors or the vulnerabilities that threat actors can exploit to penetrate a target network or damage an organization somehow An unused and forgotten subdomain for instance can become an attack vector when taken over Certain categories of companies have very large attack surfaces Such ..
Is 5G a Race We Want to Win? (2020-10-29) There is an interesting article recently published in the English version of a South Korean newspaper the ChosunILBO that talks about 5G in China According to the article the Chinese 5G rollout is an expensive bust There are a number of interesting facts disclosed about the Chinese 5G rollout First its clear that the rollout is using millimeter wave spectrum The article says that the 5G towers in .. Is 5G a Race We Want to Win?