Colorado Voters Continue To Peck Away At State Law Restricting Community Broadband
We’ve long mentioned how incumbent ISPs like ATT and Comcast have spent millions of dollars quite literally buying shitty, protectionist laws in around twenty states that either ban or heavily hamstring towns and cities from building their own broadband networks. In some cases these laws ban municipalities from even engaging in public/private partnerships. It’s a scenario where ISPs get to have th
eir cake and eat it too; they often refuse to upgrade their networks in under-served areas (particularly true among telcos offering DSL), but also get to write shitty laws preventing these under-served towns from doing anything about it.
This dance of dysfunction has been particularly interesting in Colorado, however. While lobbyists for Comcast and CenturyLink managed to convince state leaders to pass such a law (SB 152) in 2005, the legislation contains a provision that lets individual Colorado towns and cities ignore the measure with a simple referendum. With frustration mounting over sub-standard broadband and awful customer service, more than 100 towns and cities have done so thus far. And that was before a pandemic highlighted the urgent importance of broadband for public safety.
The trend continued this month, when the vast majority of Colorado voters (82%) voted to opt out of the state law restricting community broadband. According to the Institute for Local Self-Reliance, several other communities voted along the same lines, and more than 140 Colorado communities have done the same in the fifteen years since the Colorado law was passed:
“Two other Colorado communities – Berthoud and Englewood – also voted in favor of similar ballot questions, asking voters if they want to opt out of SB 152. In Berthoud, 77.3% of voters cast ballots in support of the question. In Englewood, the opt-out question passed with 79.4% of voters in favor, which will allow the city to provide Wi-Fi service in city facilities.
In the 15 years since SB 152 was passed 140 Colorado communities have opted out with resultant networks like Longmont’s NextLight as an example of a municipal Fiber-to-the-Home (FTTH) success story.”
While incumbent ISPs (and the regulators and lawmakers paid to love them) routinely claim community broadband is some kind of inevitable taxpayer boondoggle or nefarious affront to free speech, that’s simply never been true. Such efforts are an organic response to market failure and the lack of competition in countless markets across the United States. And data has repeatedly indicated that such projects tend to offer faster speeds and better customer service at lower, more transparent prices than incumbent cable and phone giants.
Such networks aren’t some kind of magic panacea, but they can often drive apathetic monopolies toward actually giving a damn, resulting in upgrades that wouldn’t materialize otherwise. And despite many nonsensical political narratives about community broadband being “socialism run amok,” such networks have broad bipartisan public support, and are most frequently built in Conservative areas.
Despite a lot of whining among entrenched incumbents and their army of policy voices, there’s a pretty easy way to thwart such projects: start offering better, faster, cheaper broadband service. But because that’s not profitable enough, quickly enough for Wall Street, the sector instead spends its time buying lawmakers and anti-competitive laws. In Colorado’s case, Centurylink and other backers of SB 152 likely rue the day they included an opt-out clause.
Author: Karl Bode
Date: 2020-11-16
techdirt.com
| More Evidence FCC Claims That Killing Net Neutrality Would Boost Broadband Investment Were Bullshit (2020-11-20) | Since the very beginning of the net neutrality debate ISPs have repeatedly proclaimed that net neutrality rules read: stopgap rules crafted in the absence of competition to stop giant monopolies from abusing their power utterly demolished broadband sector investment It was a primary talking point during the battle over the 2010 rules and was foundational in the Ajit Pai FCCs arguments justifying t.. More Evidence FCC Claims That Killing Net Neutrality Would Boost Broadband Investment Were Bullshit |
| White House Offers To Allow Renaming Confederate Bases… In Exchange For Getting Rid Of Section 230 (2020-11-20) | Lets state upfront that there is no way in hell this is happening and its all just performative nonsense No one is actually going to do this However the NY Times is reporting that White House chief of staff Mark Meadows has floated the idea of compromise to get the annual NDAA passed after President Trump has whined about it requiring the renaming of military bases named after Confederacy leaders .. |
| EU Takes Another Small Step Towards Trying To Ban Encryption; New Paper Argues Tech Can Nerd Harder To Backdoor Encryption (2020-11-10) | In September we noted that officials in the EU were continuing an effort to try to ban end-to-end encryption Of course thats not how they put it They say they just want lawful access to encrypted content not recognizing that any such backdoor effectively obliterates the protections of end-to-end encryption A new Draft Council Resolution on Encryption has come out as the EU Council of Ministers con.. |
| Will Parler Users Treat Its ‘Glitch’ That Hid Georgia Election Content The Same Way They Treated A Twitter Glitch? (2020-11-24) | Its been absolutely fascinating – though not at all surprising – to watch a ton of Trumpists mentally struggling with the process of understanding the nature importance and necessity of content moderation online over the last few months via Parler As you may recall after whining about being moderated on sites like Twitter and Facebook a bunch of Trump fans started using Parler a site that was on.. |
| ‘Tis The Season: Congress Looks To Sneak In Unconstitutional Copyright Reform Bill Into ‘Must Pass’ Spending Bill (2020-12-01) | If you have to sneak your transformational copyright bill into a must pass government spending bill it seems fairly evident that you know the bill is bad Earlier we talked about how the White House is trying to slip a Section 230 repeal into the NDAA military appropriations bill and now weve heard multiple people confirm that theres an effort underway to slip the CASE Act into the must pass govern.. |
| WHO Is Blocking Commenters From Even Mentioning Taiwan On Its Facebook Page (2020-11-12) | A few months back we highlighted the insane lengths the WHO was going to in an effort to silence Taiwan despite that countrys extraordinarily successful efforts to combat COVID-19 Yes yes everyone understands the geopolitical mess in that the Chinese government refuses to recognize that Taiwan is an independent country which everyone who lives in reality knows and that various organizations and go.. |
| Trump’s DOJ Still Pretending Everything Has An ‘Interstate’ Nexus To Throw Federal Charges At Protester (2020-11-04) | The Trump Administrations desire to turn protests against police brutality into an antifa conspiracy have failed But not for a lack of trying Federal officers have been sent to major cities still experiencing unrest but arrest data and DOJ press releases show theres very little evidence that coordinated groups of anarchists are behind the violence and property destruction witnessed around the nati.. |
| Happy 20th Birthday To ‘No One Lives Forever’, The Classic PC Game That Can’t Be Sold Today Thanks To IP (2020-11-11) | There are a great many interesting arguments we tend to have over both the purpose of copyright law and how effectively its current application aligns with that purpose Still we are on fairly solid legal footing when we state that the main thrust of copyright was supposed to be to drive more and better content to the public Much of the disagreement we tend to have with naysayers revolves around wh.. |
| U.S. Broadband Speeds Jumped 90% in 2020. But No, It Had Nothing To Do With Killing Net Neutrality. (2020-12-03) | Last last week a report out of the UK topped the trending news items at Hacker News The report found that US broadband speeds – historically the poster child for mediocrity – jumped roughly 90% during the COVID-19 lockdowns The improvements werent consistent geographically and the report was quick to note that by and large the US remains relatively mediocre when it comes to broadband speeds in l.. U.S. Broadband Speeds Jumped 90% in 2020. But No, It Had Nothing To Do With Killing Net Neutrality. |
| Twitch’s No Good, Very Bad Time Continues: Part 1 (2020-11-18) | Im beginning to wonder if the folks that run Twitch are secretly attempting to commit corporate suicide The past several weeks have seen the popular streaming platform embroiled in controversy It began when in response to the RIAA labels DMCA attacks on streamers Twitch took the unprecedented step to simply nuke a zillion hours of recorded content without warning its creators In the wake of that t.. |
