October 13, 2020

1396 words 7 mins read

Ajit Pais FCC Does Something Good Frees Wireless Spectrum The Auto Industry Had Done Little With

Ajit Pais FCC Does Something Good Frees Wireless Spectrum The Auto Industry Had Done Little With

While we’ve had no shortage of criticism for Ajit Pai’s facts-optional, relentless ass kissing of entrenched telecom monopolies, or his wholesale demolition of U.S. consumer protection, his agency has done a good job bringing more wireless spectrum to market. Doing so wasn’t particularly controversial, since everybody, consumers to big carriers alike, benefit from having access to more spectrum –

especially valuable middleband spectrum of great use in 5G deployments. Still, it’s complicated and warrants kudos in an era when government often can’t tie its own shoes correctly.

Last week, the FCC quietly voted unanimously to add 45MHz of spectrum to Wi-Fi to public access, taking it away from an auto industry public safety initiative that failed to materialize over the last 20 years. Spectrum in the 5.850GHz to 5.925GHz range for several decades had been set aside for something called Dedicated Short Range Communications (DSRC), a vehicle-to-vehicle and vehicle-to-infrastructure communications system that was supposed to warn drivers of traffic dangers. But decades in, 99.9943% of cars still don’t have the technology, and many experts had argued this spectrum was better used elsewhere.

Because this spectrum aids his industry BFFs, Pai was keen on moving forward in ensuring this spectrum could be put to better use. Both consumer groups and telecom policy and lobbying groups agreed with the decision, which hasn’t happened all that often in the last four years. Public Knowledge counsel Harold Feld, who probably knows more about U.S. spectrum policy than anybody alive, had this to say of the move:

“The addition of 45 MHz of unlicensed spectrum will create a WiFi channel capable of supporting WiFi 6. This will enable wireless providers to dramatically increase the speed and reliability of rural broadband. It will dramatically increase the power of public hotspots and mobile hotspots on which many low-income families rely for access to school and work during the pandemic. Because this relies on already existing technology, the expansion and change to WiFi 6 can happen relatively quickly through software upgrades once the rules become effective.”

DSRC services now have to vacate the lower 45MHz within one year. The FCC also set aside around 30MHz for a newer vehicle safety technology dubbed Cellular Vehicle-to-Everything (C-V2X), which the FCC claims will serve the same function using less overall precious spectrum.

The decision wasn’t entirely without controversy. The Department of Transit wasn’t thrilled, arguing that DSRC tech still could have been useful, that 30 MHz wasn’t enough for C-V2X to work (“there is sufficient evidence to demonstrate that 30 MHz will suffice to support a safety-driven ecosystem like the one in which DOT and other stakeholders have invested."). The auto industry (which had been accused of “spectrum squatting”) understandably opposed the ruling via its various policy organizations. Other critics like Senator Maria Cantwell argued the FCC had been told to pause all controversial decisions during the transition, which is custom.

Still, you’d be hard pressed to find an issue where this FCC and consumer groups align, so progress is progress, even if not everybody’s happy with the outcome. Of course, this doesn’t make up for Pai’s long history of demolishing U.S. consumer protection on behalf of telecom monopolies in fits of lies and rank hypocrisy, but it’s still nice to see (most) folks agree on one of his last major decisions as agency boss.

Author: Karl Bode

Date: 2020-11-25

URL: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20201119/08503745736/ajit-pais-fcc-does-something-good-frees-wireless-spectrum-auto-industry-had-done-little-with.shtml


Content Moderation Case Study: Facebook Attracts International Attention When It Removes A Historic Vietnam War Photo Posted By The Editor-in-Chief Of Norway’s Biggest Newspaper (2016) (2020-11-20) Summary: Tom Egeland a Norwegian author of a number of best-selling fiction books posted a well-known photo known as The Terror of War to Facebook The historic photograph taken by Vietnamese-American photographer Nick Ut depicts a naked Vietnamese girl running from a napalm attack during the Vietnam War Uts iconic photo brought the horrors of the war in Vietnam to viewers around the world But it w..
Daily Deal: The Unity 2D Game Developer Bundle (2020-11-02) The Unity 2D Game Developer Bundle has 11 courses to help you learn how to create your own games Youll learn how to create awesome replicas of the games that dominated the early 80s and 90s Youll also learn how these groundbreaking titles function and recreate them with Unity 2D The bundle is on sale for $40 Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackCommerce A portion of all sa..
Ajit Pai, Easily The Most Controversial FCC Boss In History, Will Step Down January 20 (2020-11-30) While many GOP members continue to happily undermine democracy by fueling Trumps baseless electoral fraud claims FCC boss Ajit Pai wont be coming along for the ride In a statement Pai confirmed that as is custom hell be stepping down as agency head on January 20 as the Biden administration takes over Historically the party that controls the White House controls both a 3-2 commissioner majority and.. Ajit Pai, Easily The Most Controversial FCC Boss In History, Will Step Down January 20
Instructors And School Administrators Are Somehow Managing To Make Intrusive Testing Spyware Even Worse (2020-11-17) The COVIDian dystopia continues After a brief respite infections and deaths have surged strongly suggesting the were not doing anything about it plan adopted by many states is fattening the curve With infections spreading once again the ushering of children back to school seems to have been short-sighted But not all the kids are in school Some are still engaged in distance learning For many this m..
‘You Have Zero Privacy’ Say RCMP Social Media Surveillance Documents Before Going On To Demonstrate Why (2020-11-19) The Royal Canadian Mounted Police have eyes everywhere Thats according to documents obtained via public records requests by The Tyee which published selections from the 3000 pages it has spent more than a year suing to obtain The RCMP has made news previously for doing things like sidestepping warrant requirements for obtaining user data from ISPs and dropping criminal cases rather than discuss it..
Three TikTok Influencers Influenced A Judge To Block Trump’s TikTok Ban (2020-11-02) Remember Trumps ridiculous executive order to ban TikTok if it wasnt sold to an American company? Then there was a grifty non-deal in which Oracle agreed to host TikToks new American subsidiary though nothing about that deal appears to have been finalized and the executive order was still somewhat in place The first stage of the ban on the app was blocked by a judge in a lawsuit from TikTok itself..
Nikola’s Bad Quarter: Company’s Deal For General Motors Ownership Stake Goes Sideways (2020-12-03) The trouble for Nikola Motor Company began only in September a couple of months ago Thats when a hedge fund very publicly called out the company and its founder Trevor Milton for essentially fooling people with doctored video of its electric semi-truck product to get them to invest in the company This led to rumors of federal investigations the resignation of Milton and the company idiotically try..
Bad Analogy: Comparing Social Media To Guns (2020-11-20) Weve been seeing all sorts of really dumb analogies lately as people try to complain about social media During the recent Senate hearing about social media and content moderation Senators from both parties compared social media to cigarette smoking somehow ignoring the fact that in that analogy the tobacco is 1st Amendment protected speech But Reuters decided to one up that and compare social medi..
What The Election Means For Tech (2020-11-03) If Trump Wins For Republicans bashing Big Tech has become as central to the Culture War as bashing the Big Three Networks once was Demanding neutrality from social media companies has become what net neutrality has been for Democrats: the issue that sucks up all the oxygen in the room except far more politically useful ISPs arent in the content moderation business but social media would be unusabl.. What The Election Means For Tech
Devin Nunes Files Another SLAPP Suit; Sues The Washington Post Again (2020-11-18) Devin Nunes is one of the most vocal supporters of Parler regularly insisting that he supports Parler because Parler supports free speech of course as weve highlighted Parler blocks users quite frequently contrary to its marketing claims Of course Nunes is a free speech hypocrite As weve highlighted over the last few years he seems to have an itchy trigger finger when it comes to suing the media a..