November 28, 2020

1630 words 8 mins read

US Broadband Speeds Jumped 90% in 2020 But No It Had Nothing To Do With Killing Net Neutrality

US Broadband Speeds Jumped 90% in 2020 But No It Had Nothing To Do With Killing Net Neutrality

Last last week, a report out of the UK topped the trending news items at Hacker News. The report found that U.S. broadband speeds – historically the poster child for mediocrity – jumped roughly 90% during the COVID-19 lockdowns. The improvements weren’t consistent geographically, and the report was quick to note that by and large, the U.S. remains relatively mediocre when it comes to broadband s

peeds (in large part due to limited competition):

“The US stills lags behind many European and developed nations worldwide, and its major cities also often lag behind their European equivalents. That said, there is cause for celebration in Dallas, Seattle and Austin, after our analysis has shown that these cities are performing extremely well relative to most European capital cities.”

I spoke briefly to study author Thomas Buck after he reached out to note that folks were misinterpreting his study. Yes, the study shows U.S. broadband speeds jumped 90% in 2020. But Buck also notes this likely isn’t because of policy decisions at the FCC, or because ISPs did much of anything differently. It’s most likely because when consumers were forced to stay home to work and attend school during COVID lockdown, they were simply willing to pay more money for already available, faster speeds because they realized faster broadband was essential. Buck put it this way:

“… the findings are more likely to suggest increased consumer spending on high-speed plans for working from home than anything else…speed test data is fascinating and helpful, but using it as proof that net neutrality was bad is a giant stretch by any means. When looking at broadband data, I think its more important to discuss the dark spots (subscriber data, full capacity testing at scale, same-year fiber build data) than what we have (hundreds of thousands of speed tests, most of them showing results a fraction of what ISPs advertise).”

Yet a number of folks (including commenters at Hacker News) set to work trying to claim that this sudden boost in speed was courtesy of the FCC’s decision to kill net neutrality and effectively self-immolate at telecom lobbyist behest. It’s part of a fairly relentless attempt to proclaim that because killing net neutrality didn’t immediately result in a rainbow-colored explosion, the repeal itself must have somehow been a good thing.

For example, this entire thread from a Federalist contributor takes the study and creates an elaborate alternate reality where critics of the net neutrality repeal must have been wrong, because (you guessed it) the internet didn’t immediately come to a stop:


Three years ago, America was locked in a battle for #NetNeutrality, and, by extension, life as we knew it.

For the lucky few who survived, I invite you to join me on a quick stroll down memory lane to revisit the doom and gloom we were promised.

Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) November 25, 2020

Yes, many activists and supporters of net neutrality were hyperbolic in trying to explain the very real, very negative impact the net neutrality repeal would have over the longer term. That doesn’t mean it wasn’t a terrible idea done in exclusive service to telecom monopolies.

Once again, killing net neutrality didn’t just kill fairly modest net neutrality rules. It left the FCC incapable of holding giant ISPs accountable for fraud, anti-competitive behavior, predatory billing, bogus fees, privacy violations, and all the other symptoms of a broken, uncompetitive, and highly geographically monopolized U.S. telecom market. If you think that’s a good thing (especially during a massive economic and public health crisis that has shown broadband to be an essential lifeline), you either don’t understand how any of this works, or are being intentionally misleading.

Speaking of misleading, the study also appears to have popped up in FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr’s goodbye letter to Ajit Pai (pdf), in which he attributes the speed jump to Pai’s incredible leadership:

“With Internet speeds more than doubling under his leadership, America is now home to the strongest 5G platform in the world.”

That is, if you’re playing along at home, not true. 83 million Americans live under a broadband monopoly. Tens of millions more live under a broadband duopoly. Americans pay some of the highest prices in the world for what’s routinely patchy service, mediocre speeds, and terrible customer service. And U.S. 5G speeds also provably and dramatically lag behind most other developed nations as well. There’s a reason for this: it’s called regulatory capture and mindless pandering to powerful telecom monopolies. Resulting in the FCC effectively dismantling itself because Comcast and ATT told it to.

Again, if you genuinely think having chickenshit regulators commit seppuku because some widely despised telecom monopolists told them to is a good thing, you’re either very confused as to how absolutely any of this works, or you’re being intentionally misleading. Possibly both.

Author: Karl Bode

Date: 2020-12-03


Bad Analogy: Comparing Social Media To Guns (2020-11-20) Weve been seeing all sorts of really dumb analogies lately as people try to complain about social media During the recent Senate hearing about social media and content moderation Senators from both parties compared social media to cigarette smoking somehow ignoring the fact that in that analogy the tobacco is 1st Amendment protected speech But Reuters decided to one up that and compare social medi..
Cities Say ISPs Are Being Cagey About Low-Income Broadband Availability During Covid (2020-11-17) Back in March the Trump FCC put on a big show about a new Keep America Connected Pledge to help broadband users during COVID In it the FCC proudly proclaimed that it had gotten hundreds of ISPs to suspend usage caps and late fees and agree to not disconnect users who couldnt pay for essential broadband service during a pandemic The problem: the 60 day pledge was entirely voluntary temporary and be..
Kentucky State Police ‘Warrior Mindset’ Training Presentation Quotes Robert E. Lee, Adolph Hitler (2020-11-05) Law enforcement training is sketchy stuff We didnt get to where we are today without telling a blend of do-gooders and bullies that its the public whos wrong and the blue line warriors who are right The us vs them mindset seems to have accelerated in recent years urged on by overheated rhetoric about criminals outgunning the cops despite historically-low crime rates and the federal governments wil..
Bethesda, Microsoft Make Conflicting Statements About Game Exclusivity After Studio Purchase (2020-11-02) Several weeks ago Microsoft bought Zenimax Media the parent organization of Bethesda Softworks for over $7 billion Bethesda is a celebrated studio best known for its Fallout and Elder Scrolls titles Both series have long histories of being published across a wide range of gaming platforms including the PC PlayStation and Xbox markets Almost immediately after the deal however many gamers openly wor..
Happy 20th Birthday To ‘No One Lives Forever’, The Classic PC Game That Can’t Be Sold Today Thanks To IP (2020-11-11) There are a great many interesting arguments we tend to have over both the purpose of copyright law and how effectively its current application aligns with that purpose Still we are on fairly solid legal footing when we state that the main thrust of copyright was supposed to be to drive more and better content to the public Much of the disagreement we tend to have with naysayers revolves around wh..
Twitch’s No Good, Very Bad Time Continues: Part 1 (2020-11-18) Im beginning to wonder if the folks that run Twitch are secretly attempting to commit corporate suicide The past several weeks have seen the popular streaming platform embroiled in controversy It began when in response to the RIAA labels DMCA attacks on streamers Twitch took the unprecedented step to simply nuke a zillion hours of recorded content without warning its creators In the wake of that t..
Gun-Toting Couple Sues Photographer For Privacy Violation Over Photo They Used As Christmas Cards, After He Billed Them (2020-11-11) Youve heard of Mark and Patricia McCloskey by now They are the St Louis couple who waved guns at various protesters who entered their gated street in the process of marching to the nearby mayors home demanding the mayors resignation The McCloskeys seem to have quite the reputation as not the greatest of neighbors and seem to have very strong opinions about their property The pictures and videos of..
Disney (Disney!) Accused Of Trying To Lawyer Its Way Out Of Paying Royalties To Alan Dean Foster (2020-11-19) Disney of course has quite the reputation as a copyright maximalist It has been accused of being the leading company in always pushing for more draconian copyright laws And then of course theres the infamous Mickey Mouse curve first designated a decade ago by Tom Bell highlighting how copyright term extensions seemed to always happen just as Mickey Mouse was set to go into the public domain though..
Daily Deal: The Ultimate Cartoon Animator 4 Pro Windows Bundle (2020-12-02) The Ultimate Cartoon Animator 4 Pro Windows Bundle has 2 courses to help you learn how to bring your own images and characters to life Cartoon Animator 4 formerly known as CrazyTalk Animator is a 2D animation software optimized for both abilities of entry and productivity You can turn images into animated characters generate lip-sync animation from audio accomplish 3D parallax scenes produce 2D vi..
Comcast Tells Customers They May Lose Access To Comcast Channels If Comcast Can’t Agree With Comcast (2020-11-04) Comcast is informing the companys 20+ million cable TV customers that they may lose access to Comcast TV channels next month if Comcast cant come to some sort of agreement with Comcast Its an absurd twist on the already annoying practice of carriage disputes where customers pay the price for broadcasters and cable TV providers being unable to come to terms on new agreements after old ones expire U..