September 24, 2020

1459 words 7 mins read

More Evidence FCC Claims That Killing Net Neutrality Would Boost Broadband Investment Were Bullshit

More Evidence FCC Claims That Killing Net Neutrality Would Boost Broadband Investment Were Bullshit

Since the very beginning of the net neutrality debate, ISPs have repeatedly proclaimed that net neutrality rules (read: stopgap rules crafted in the absence of competition to stop giant monopolies from abusing their power) utterly demolished broadband sector investment. It was a primary talking point during the battle over the 2010 rules, and was foundational in the Ajit Pai FCC’s arguments justif

ying their hugely unpopular and fraud prone repeal.

Time after time after time, big ISPs and the politicians paid to love them insisted that the rules had crushed sector investment, and repealing them would result in a massive spike in broadband investment. It was a line repeated again by Pai during an FCC oversight hearing in 2018 (for those interested he wasn’t under oath, which applies only to Judiciary hearings):

“Under the heavy-handed regulations adopted by the prior Commission in 2015, network investment declined for two straight years, the first time that had happened outside of a recession in the broadband era…we now have a regulatory framework in place that is encouraging the private sector to make the investments necessary to bring better, faster, and cheaper broadband to more Americans.”

The problem: a mountain of data continues to make it extremely clear that none of this was ever true.

Numerous studies, earnings reports, and CEO statements had already demolished the claim, yet like a relentless zombie, it simply refuses to die. To this day it remains a core talking point of the outgoing Ajit Pai FCC, most telecom lobbyists, and the absolute army of think tankers, consultants, and academics employed by incumbent telecom giants to pretend the U.S. broadband market is healthy and competitive.

This week, SP Global took a closer look at U.S. network investment numbers and found, once again, that claims that repealing network neutrality boosted investment to be bullshit. In fact, the firm found that annual investment in fixed U.S. broadband networks is poised to have dropped 7 percent since 2016:

Getting rid of Net Neutrality (Trumps FCC) was supposed to boost incentives to invest in broadband. Guess what? In our hour of greatest need, investment way down since 2016 ! It was just another pack of lies

Tim Wu (@superwuster) November 19, 2020

Granted the telecom sector has been in the U.S. government’s driver’s seat under the Trump administration. In just four short years the industry successfully had broadband privacy rules killed (thanks to GOP Senators), net neutrality rules killed, FCC authority over telecom monopolies kneecapped, and the sector received billions in tax breaks in exchange for doing absolutely nothing. The telecom sector even managed to convince most of DC that “big tech” monopolies are the only monopolies in tech worth worrying about. All in all, a pretty good four years for one of the least liked, least competitive sectors in U.S. industry.

All of this industry ass kissing would, to hear industry and loyal lawmakers tell it, boost network investment, increase employment, and drive more innovation and competition to market. None of that happened. Why? Because when you eliminate all meaningful oversight from a broken, monopolized sector, the companies involved simply double down on the same bad behaviors (layoffs, price hikes, less investment in infrastructure and customer support). Yet for whatever reason, we cling desperately to “free market” narratives that don’t apply to a broken sector that sees little real competition and has an unrelenting political stranglehold on both state and federal leaders. No competition and no oversight means more of the same problems.

Of course the sagging investment, eroded regulatory authority, and tens of thousands of layoffs come just as a raging pandemic showcases how broadband (and objective federal leadership on broadband) is more essential than ever. And cocksure policy pundits or campaign-contribution-slathered lawmakers won’t learn much of anything from the experience, because there will be absolutely no penalty whatsoever for pushing bullshit narratives or relentlessly kissing the ass of a broken, monopolized market.

Author: Karl Bode

Date: 2020-11-20


Content Moderation Case Study: Moderating An Anonymous Social Network (2015) (2020-11-04) Summary: Between around 2013 and 2015 there was a sudden popularity of so-called anonymous social networks A few had existed before but suddenly the market was full of them: Whisper Secret and Yik Yak received the most attention All of them argued that by allowing people to post content anonymously they were helping people allowing them to express their true thoughts rather than repress them Whisp..
Bethesda, Microsoft Make Conflicting Statements About Game Exclusivity After Studio Purchase (2020-11-02) Several weeks ago Microsoft bought Zenimax Media the parent organization of Bethesda Softworks for over $7 billion Bethesda is a celebrated studio best known for its Fallout and Elder Scrolls titles Both series have long histories of being published across a wide range of gaming platforms including the PC PlayStation and Xbox markets Almost immediately after the deal however many gamers openly wor..
Day After Senator Lindsey Graham Is Credibly Accused Of Trying To Undermine The Election, He Hosts Hearing Attacking Social Media For Undermining Election (2020-11-18) The timing on this is quite incredible On Monday Georgias Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger spoke out saying that Senator Lindsey Graham had called him and implied that Raffensperger should look to throw out ballots that were legally cast in the state On Tuesday morning in trying to defend his efforts to undermine the election Graham tried to shake off his calls with Raffensperger a..
This Week In Techdirt History: November 29th - December 5th (2020-12-05) Five Years Ago This week in 2015 details were continuing to emerge that showed the Paris attackers made very little effort to hide themselves while the French government was using the state of emergency as an excuse to round up climate change activists and some in the US were using the San Bernadino shooting to push for more domestic surveillance New problems were being discovered with the UKs sno..
Mine, Mine, Mine! Nintendo Neuters The Cool Ways People, Groups Are Using ‘Animal Crossing’ (2020-11-24) To be honest Animal Crossing was always going to be a hit Its just the perfect distillation of the Nintendo experience: a cutesy social experience couched in harmless video game fun Still one unanticipated side effect of the global COVID-19 pandemic was how plenty of people and groups turned to the game for new and innovative ways of connecting with others Examples abound including players buildin..
Twitch Continues To Trip Over Itself In Response To DMCA Apocalypse (2020-11-16) What a few weeks for Twitch You will recall that the platform went about pissing a ton of its talent and viewers off by nuking a metric ton of video content on the site in response to a flood of DMCA takedown notices most of them from the RIAA And this truly was the nuclear option far different from the notice/counternotice system most platforms use In fact it was so extraordinary that it arguably..
US Cybersecurity Director Expecting To Be Fired After Refusing To Edit Page Debunking Election Hacking Myths (2020-11-13) One of the few parts of the federal government that hasnt dissolved into a complete partisan trash heap was the newly created Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency CISA a division of Homeland Security that was created as part of the problematic CISA bill five years ago While we were disappointed in many aspects of the bill itself as an organization CISA has done some pretty good work in..
California Court Says Wiretap Target Should Have Access To Wiretap Documents (2020-11-06) The EFF – representing former California Highway Patrol officer Miguel Guerrero – has achieved a significant legal victory The California Appeals Court has given citizens a better shot at demanding law enforcement transparency about intrusive surveillance efforts Its incredibly difficult to unseal documents the government wants to keep hidden especially when the government raises arguments about..
This Week In Techdirt History: November 8th - 14th (2020-11-14) Five Years Ago This week in 2015 we looked at early warnings of the EUs all-out attack on hyperlinks while the silly Monkey Selfie lawsuit was winding forward and a new surprise player entered the copyright fight over Happy Birthday The MPAAs attempt to sneak SOPA in the back door was rejected but the agency was getting cozy with the House Judiciary Committee And we looked at the unsurprising trio..
Beijing Tightens Grip On Hong Kong With Arrest Of Pro-Democracy Lawmakers (2020-11-19) Literally everyone saw this coming On the heels of a rushed through resolution out of mainland China that ousted four pro-democracy Hong Kong lawmakers leading to the resignation of every other pro-democracy lawmaker as well the question was when not if Beijing would continue to tighten its communist grip The answer to that question appears to be almost immediately with China announcing the arrest..