Bullshit Broadband Usage Caps Are Hugely Profitable During A Pandemic
We’ve noted for years how broadband providers have increasingly imposed arbitrary, confusing, and punitive usage caps and overage fees to cash in on the lack of competition in US broadband. Not only have industry executives admitted these limits aren’t technically necessary, they’ve increasingly been abused to hamstring competitors. AT&T, for example, doesn’t impose the limits on its broadband cus
tomers who use its streaming video service (AT&T Now), but will impose the added charges if you use a competitor like Netflix.
For more than a decade ISPs have slowly but surely imposed such limits hoping that consumers wouldn’t notice (think of the frog in the pot of boiling water metaphor with you as the frog). But with most folks stuck at home during an historic health and economic crisis, bandwidth usage (and thereby profits gleaned by usage caps) has grown significantly. In fact, data from OpenVault indicates that the number of broadband “power users,” or users who consume more than a terabyte per month, has doubled over the past year:
“In Q3 2020, 8.8 percent of broadband subscribers used at least 1TB per month, up from 4.2 percent in Q3 2019, according to a study released yesterday by OpenVault. OpenVault is a vendor that sells a data-usage tracking platform to cable, fiber, and wireless ISPs and has 150 operators as customers worldwide. The 8.8- and 4.2-percent figures refer to US customers only, an OpenVault spokesperson told Ars.”
Cross this phony threshold and you wind up owing your ISP even more money, despite Americans already paying some of the highest prices for broadband in the developed world – a notorious metric that doesn’t even include the additional costs incurred by usage caps, overage fees, and other nonsensical surcharges the industry uses to falsely advertise a lower rate. If you’re a telecom monopoly, this is all great. If you’re an American struggling to pay your broadband bill, suddenly higher due to household video streaming, gaming, school work, regular work, and video conferencing, it’s decidedly less so.
OpenVault of course advises ISPs to embrace caps because it means more users will be paying more money over time than ISPs that don’t:
“In potentially bad news for customers, OpenVault seems to be urging ISPs that haven’t imposed data caps to adopt them. “The goal for network operators is to ensure that subscribers who consume the most bandwidth are in faster, higher ARPU [average revenue per user] speed tiers,” OpenVault said. “Usage-based billing operators are achieving this goal more, on average, than network operators who utilize flat-rate unlimited billing.”
But again, the problem is that such restrictions are bullshit. They do not manage congestion. They aren’t required for network management because they don’t really help network strain. They’re glorified price hikes by natural monopolies on captive customers who can’t vote with their wallets. They’re not even necessary as a product differentiator, as the heaviest users can already be shoved toward business-class tiers. They exist solely to extract an additional pound of flesh from uncompetitive U.S. broadband markets. And now they’re being exploited during a national crisis.
The Trump FCC made some performative, empty gestures toward this problem earlier this year when it announced an entirely voluntary pledge with ISPs, who agreed they’d temporarily stop charging late fees or imposing usage caps. Many ISPs not only ignored their promise, but it was only a few months before most ISPs returned to business as usual, hitting struggling Americans with all manner of spurious additional charges.
Of course you’d never realize such limits are bullshit reading outlets like the Wall Street Journal, which recently parroted industry claims like caps are necessary to “keep the prices of internet packages stable by shifting the extra cost to heavy users,” (nonsense, everybody pays more under such a model as the average usage rate creeps skyward), or “protect the majority of subscribers from having rates raised every year” (also nonsense, given U.S. broadband flat rate prices and other fees routinely increase your costs either way).
It’s just monopolies being monopolies, and there’s a sizeable industry of think tankers, consultants, academics, and lobbying firms funded by the U.S. telecom sector whose entire job is to pretend that’s not actually a problem.
Author: Karl Bode
Date: 2020-11-18
techdirt.com
| Daily Deal: Python For Beginners (2020-11-03) | Python is a high-level statically typed programming language that has become a trendsetter in the industry It offers an easy syntax and a wide support for APIs and external packages Python is extremely versatile it can be used for automation GUI Applications making websites making web apps and even for hacking! In the Python for Beginners course you are going to learn the basics of the Python lang.. |
| Trump’s FCC Nominee Asked Fox News To Help Destroy Section 230 To Help Elect More Republicans (2020-11-25) | Weve written a few times about Nathan Simington who is currently nominated to take over Michael ORiellys seat at the FCC As youll recall ORiellys renomination was withdrawn after he dared to give a talk in which he noted accurately that the 1st Amendment means that the government cannot regulate how private companies handle content moderation Simington in contrast to ORielly has been at the center.. |
| Trump Doubles Down On Threat To Defund Military Because People Are Mean To Him Online; Republicans Threaten To Override His Veto (2020-12-04) | On Tuesday we highlighted that it looked like Congressional Republicans were willing to finally stand up to their partys insecure and whiny lame duck president and refuse to include a Section 230 repeal as part of the military authorization bill the NDAA Senator Jim Inhofe who heads the Senate Armed Services Committee and who lead the negotiation on the bill has been a longtime supporter of the Pr.. |
| President-For-Life Hopeful Donald Trump Issues Executive Order Mandating ‘Patriotic’ Education For Kids (2020-11-04) | When schools finally re-open to everyone and COVID is behind us est 2025 students will possibly have the chance to join their friends in some good old-fashioned American reeducation God bless this autocracy For all of his socialism bashing Donald Trump and his admin staff sure seem to want to align the United States with the great Communist dictatorships of the past and present Trump welcomed Amer.. |
| Comcast Increases Prices And Bogus Fees In The Middle Of A Pandemic (2020-12-02) | Last week we noted how Comcast had expanded its bullshit broadband usage caps during a pandemic insisting that the confusing technically-unnecessary restrictions were being deployed in an alleged act of fairness Of course as we noted theres nothing fair about costly punitive surcharges that serve absolutely no technical purpose and exist exclusively so a monopoly can extract additional revenue fro.. Comcast Increases Prices And Bogus Fees In The Middle Of A Pandemic |
| Supreme Court Rejects Appeals Court’s Revival Of Anonymous Cop’s Stupid Lawsuit Against BLM Activist (2020-11-03) | Early last year the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals which has more than its fair share of inexplicable decisions released an inexplicable decision The appeal arose from a lower courts dismissal of an injured cops lawsuit against multiple parties over injuries he sustained when a protester threw a chunk of concrete at him The pseudonymous cop sued a number of entities including Black Lives Matter a .. |
| Appeals Court Strips Immunity From Detectives Who Turned A Rape Report Into 18 Hours Of Terror For The Victim (2020-11-12) | This recent decision PDF by the First Circuit Court of Appeals details a law enforcement enabled nightmare – one that saw the plaintiff shot by the same person who had raped her earlier and someone the police were supposed to be trying to locate So much for the Thin Blue Line The line never materialized here and in fact took affirmative steps to erase what little line there actually was Theres a .. |
| Trump Campaign Gets Laughed Out Of Court For Claiming A Bunch Of Unvetted Webform Submissions Is ‘Evidence’ Of Voter Fraud (2020-11-13) | The Trump Campaign is back in court hoping to reclaim a presidency Donald Trump has lost It spent plenty of time in court prior to the election hoping to prevent as many people as possible from voting Now its doing the same thing insisting without evidence theres voter fraud everywhere Immediately following Election Day the Trump campaign opened its own voter fraud hotlines People who thought they.. |
| US Military Is Buying Location Data From Data Brokers, Including Data Pulled From US App Users (2020-11-20) | As long as government agencies are buying location data from data brokers – possibly eluding warrant requirements while doing so – it makes sense the US military would be doing the same thing Joseph Cox reports for Motherboard that the American war machine loves location data pulled from phone apps just as much as CBP ICE and the Secret Service do Through public records interviews with developer.. |
| Upload Filters And The Internet Architecture: What’s There To Like? (2020-11-16) | In August 2012 YouTube briefly took down a video that had been uploaded by NASA The video which depicted a landing on Mars was caught by YouTubes Content ID system as a potential copyright infringement case but like everything else NASA creates it was in the public domain Then in 2016 YouTubes automated algorithms removed another video this time a lecture by a Harvard Law professor which included .. |
