October 12, 2020

1780 words 9 mins read

COVID-19: four ways to respond to vaccine sceptics and maybe even convince them

COVID-19: four ways to respond to vaccine sceptics and maybe even convince them

There are productive ways to talk to people you disagree with. CREATISTAFor most of the 20th century, more than 60,000 people died in the US from polio, diphtheria and small pox each year. In 2016, the American death toll from these diseases was zero. Around the globe, two to three million deaths from these diseases and others, including measles, rubella and tetanus, are prevented each year.

Th

ese remarkable statistics are a triumph of medicine and the single most effective public health measure in history: global vaccination programmes.

COVID-19, after the most rapid and sustained vaccine development programme in history, now looks set to be joining this list of fatal diseases that can be easily prevented with a jab or two. The disease that has killed an estimated 1.3 million people (and rising), may have had its day. Sadly, there’s a lot of misinformation surrounding vaccinations, threatening the success of inoculation programmes.

So what can you do to protect yourself against misinformation and challenge it in conversation with others?

  1. Understand who you are talking to

Let’s not forget that the majority of people are happy to receive a COVID vaccine (64%, according to a recent study). Only a small minority (9%) have no intention of getting vaccinated. If you enter into a debate about vaccination it may well be with someone who falls into this latter group. You are very unlikely to change the minds of these vaccine refusers, so the main audience for your arguments is actually the rest of any onlooking group – and particularly the 27% who are hesitant about vaccination.

The point of your discussion is to empower the members of the audience with knowledge and arguments. To do so, it’s important to find common ground and “bond” with whoever you are talking to, rather than just lecturing them.

  1. Inoculate against misinformation

There are numerous examples of misinformation “sticking” in our individual and social memories, despite repeated attempts to dislodge it – such as the false “fact” that humans have just five senses. Rather than fighting false facts, the better option is to enable people to spot misinformation before it percolates through society and becomes “endemic” as an accepted truth.

The Debunking Handbook 2020 advocates triggering a mental “immune response” to fake news. To do so we need pre-emptive exposure to weakened versions of the manipulative strategies used by peddlers of false facts. In so doing we can inoculate against, or “prebunk”, the misinformation.

For example, once you realise that some social media users, publications and other bodies can have hidden agendas and may therefore misrepresent studies and cherry-pick information, you are better placed to assess the facts for yourself. Indeed, the tobacco and oil industries rolled out “fake experts” to create doubt that smoking causes cancers and CO₂ emissions affects our climate, respectively.

In my opinion the excellent BBC Radio 4 programme “More or Less” is a particularly good mental vaccine against misinformation.

  1. Debunk efficiently

In the midst of a debate it is probably too late to deploy any prebunking tactics. But be careful about launching into a myth-busting monologue. Simply repeating untruths risks making them stick in our memories, so instead focus your talking points on the positive outcomes of vaccinations (like the facts at the top of this article). Don’t be the first person to mention the myth.

          Measles is on the rise due to vaccine misinformation.
          Zerbor/Shutterstock

But if in the course of the conversation some misinformation does get a mention you will need to call it out. Let’s imagine you are in the midst of a debate about COVID and someone makes the claim that the 5G network is the real cause of the disease. The key to getting this debunking right is limiting how often the lie gets a mention and making the truth more sticky than the myth. Here’s how to go about it.

a) Start by stating the truth in a clear, concise way. Don’t launch into a long explanation, instead imagine you are writing a headline.

COVID is spread in droplets generated when people exhale, particularly when they cough, sneeze, or shout.

b) Point out the misinformation, and be clear that it is a myth.

The mobile network is basically a series of radio transmitters, and viruses can’t travel by radio waves.

c) Explain why the myth is wrong. You might point out some science that refutes the myth, and call out the flaws in the argument.

Besides, the COVID virus has spread throughout countries, like Iran for example, that have no 5G network.

d) Restate the facts.

  1. Think beyond facts

That said, facts alone will only go so far. The words we use are also important, they conjure up imagery that affect our response to the information we are being presented with. Consider “herds” and “communities”. Which of these would you like to be part of? Most people would say “communities”. So if you’re encouraging someone to get vaccinated, you may want to talk about their contribution to community immunity, rather than herd immunity.

Another important technique is storytelling, which can be much more effective than facts. Stories link cause and effect, making the conclusions that you want to present seem almost inevitable. For example, you may want to tell anti-vaxxers about a relative whose life was saved by a vaccine at a time when it wasn’t available to everyone.

Or you may, like the UK’s deputy chief medical officer, Jonathan Van Tam, want to stress that you have encouraged your own mother to take the vaccine, rather than just saying the elderly should take it. Mark Lorch does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Author: Mark Lorch, Professor of Science Communication and Chemistry, University of Hull

Date: 2020-11-25

URL: https://theconversation.com/covid-19-four-ways-to-respond-to-vaccine-sceptics-and-maybe-even-convince-them-150556

theconversation.com

Racism is the key to understanding ethnic inequalities in COVID-19 – despite what UK government says (2020-10-27) Weve known for some time that people from ethnic minorities in the UK are several times more likely to be admitted to hospital or die from COVID-19 A new report authored by Baroness Doreen Lawrence and commissioned by the Labour Party has found that the disease has thrived among minority communities because of inequalities driven by structural racism This contrasts significantly with the governmen..
Spotting liars is hard – but our new method is effective and ethical (2020-12-03) Guilty? The length of your answer may give it away Motortion Films/ShutterstockMost people lie occasionally The lies are often trivial and essentially inconsequential such as pretending to like a tasteless gift But in other contexts deception is more serious and can have harmful effects on criminal justice From a societal perspective such lying is better detected than ignored and tolerated Unfortu..
Asteroid Bennu: successful touchdown – but sample return mission has only just begun (2020-10-21) Artists concept of the OSIRIS REx spacecraft collecting material from Bennu NASA/Goddard Space Flight CenterRelief showed clearly on the faces of the team of NASA scientists and engineers as they were told: Touchdown is complete Then applause a few seconds later for back away burn complete The most hazardous part of the mission was over and seemingly successful although we will have to wait for a ..
The threat of ‘killer robots’ is real and closer than you might think (2020-10-15) Media Whalestock/ShutterstockFrom self-driving cars to digital assistants artificial intelligence AI is fast becoming an integral technology in our lives today But this same technology that can help to make our day-to-day life easier is also being incorporated into weapons for use in combat situations Weaponised AI features heavily in the security strategies of the US China and Russia And some exi..
A circular economy could end waste – at the cost of our privacy (2020-11-09) Elise Robert/ShutterstockIn a circular economy we wouldnt have any waste or pollution Instead everything we make and all our byproducts would be reused or repurposed helping to end the over-exploitation of our finite resources and damage to our environment and climate To make this process profitable the manufacturers of complex items such as vehicles are likely to use advanced internet-based data ..
Coronavirus is spreading rapidly through workplaces – here’s what is needed to make them safer (2020-11-03) El Nariz/ShutterstockThe small town of Watton Norfolk recently held the unfortunate title of having Englands highest rate of infection with COVID-19 relative to population size following an outbreak at a food factory Despite varying degrees of lockdown restrictions due to the pandemic many people in the UK are still going in to their workplaces Factories warehouses schools farms and some shops and..
Can you unintentionally bully someone? Here’s the science (2020-11-23) Priti Patel says she didnt intend to harm staff Facundo Arrizabalaga/EPAI was nine Some girl maybe around 15 or 16 old enough to tower over me asked whether Bill Beattie was my brother I nodded Without saying another word she grabbed me by my hair and started to drag me across the street pulling out clumps of it The whole time she was swearing about my brother how he thought he was too good for he..
Mars colony: how to make breathable air and fuel from brine – new research (2020-11-30) Artists concept of astronauts and human habitats on Mars NASANASA is planning to land a crew on the Moon by 2024 and then onward to Mars possibly in the 2030s One day we will have permanently crewed bases on both worlds Unlike the initial short-stay visits long-term bases will have to be self sufficient in as many essentials as possible A lot of research has gone into preparing for In Situ Resourc..
Curious Kids: How did some animals evolve wings to fly? (2020-10-22) Hybrid parrots in Costa Rica Ondrej Prosicky/ShutterstockHow did some animals form wings to fly? Year Five class London UK Perhaps the first thing you notice when you see a bird is its amazing ability to fly Modern birds fly using their arms which have feathers and very strong flight muscles But the ancestors of todays birds couldnt fly Birds evolved from a group of dinosaurs called theropods whic..
Hayabusa 2: returning asteroid sample could help uncover the origins of life and the solar system (2020-12-04) Artist impression of Hayabusa 2 approaching asteroid Ryugu Deutsches Zentrum fr Luft- und Raumfahrt DLR/wikipedia CC BY-SAWhat is your idea of an asteroid? Many people think of them as potato-shaped inert and perhaps rather dull pock-marked objects far away in deep space But over the last ten years two Japanese space missions Hayabusa and now Hayabusa 2 have dispatched that view to the history boo..